I Watch Musicals
Oct. 1st, 2019 02:46 pm
Beauty and the Beast- Growing up as a teen in the 90s, I saw the canonization of Disney’s films of that decade, but I get it, they are iconic. I am not sure why they need to make this as a live action movie, and I would say the same about The Lion King or Aladdin or the many others planned.
In any case, I don’t think this really moved the needle for me. Emma Watson was okay. I never was sure if she felt miscast, or more likely, she could not transcend what she had to work with. The dancing plates and candelabra that was so much fun in the cartoon, seem a bit sinister in translation. The story (though old as time, I believe) didn't help sell it either. In this context with all the Gothic shadows, it felt like a sanitized Phantom of the Opera. I think Disney really take chances with their music anymore (a million sold Frozen soundtracks would tell me otherwise), but it was pretty basic.
The whole film seemed just a bit pointless. Yes, beautifully shot, but even then, rather forgettable. To me, this would have been better off un(re) made. Still, I am sure I am not the intended audience. Worth mentioning, this really did not appeal to my young kids either, who would love the animated version.
The Greatest Showman -PT Barnum's greatest trick may be that he got the 21st Century into thinking he was the charismatic Hugh Jackman. This was a movie that was universally loved, and with reason. It's pretty fun.
It follows standard biopic tropes, which for me, I would love more, but that is how two hour Hollywood works. It's in there though (Jenny Lind, Tom Thumb, the Museum fire, etc). It takes liberties, maybe great liberties, but wouldn't that be what Barnum wanted. Jackman and cast are terrific, and it is a really beautiful movie. I thought the music was pretty good. Not quite Moulin Rouge for me, but still liked it enough.
Really, a great movie for everyone, even those who might not be drawn to musicals. My young kids were a bit bored by it, but I do hear slightly older kids love the pageantry. I love how it so easily flows and never drags.
Mary Poppins Returns -This sounds like a terrible idea, but it really is another really great movie. I was surprised, but it's not a remake, it is sort of a re-imagining, and actually hits the fine line of being respectful and being new.
Emily Blunt is dare I say, just a bit sexy. Her character takes Mary and brings her to the 21st Century. The cast is top notch - Colin Firth, Meryl Streep, Julie Walters, Linn-Manuel Miranda to name a few. Okay, Miranda's attempt at cockney, seemed like a misstep, but he sort of is charismatic enough to overcome it.
It was just a plain fun movie. The music is pretty standard, but has some fun moments that again, fit in with the spirit of the original. A lofty goal, indeed. It's a shame that Julie Andrews isn't here, but she did think she might upstage Blunt, and it's very neat to see Dick Van Dyke here as well as Angela Lansbury in a similar role. I thought the movie flowed well, and the integration of modern elements like animation really worked well.
Rob Marshall directed Chicago, and though that was a very different movie, he has a knack of making things work towards taking a musical and making it a Hollywood film. I really enjoyed this, and I would never have guessed.