Divided and United is an ambitious two-disc project helmed by Randal Poster, the music supervisor of Boardwalk Empire and Rushmore.
It is a collection of Civil war-era songs (both sides) as performed by a collection of bluegrass, traditional country, and Americana stars.
Clearly, the aim is to make a "OBrother Where Art Thou" or Will the circle be Unbroken.
The artist roster is well done- Dolly Parton, Loretta Lynn, Del McCoury, Ricky Skaggs, Lee Ann Womack, Ralph Stanley, Old Crow medicine Show, Vince Gill, Steve Earle, John Doe, Chris Thile (Nickel Creek), Pokey LaFarge, Jorma Kauoken (Hot Tuna/Jefferson Airplane), Joe Henry, Taj Mahal, Chris Hillman, and Cowboy Jack Clement.
Artists have gotten some mileage from Civil War-themed songs, but this project promises the real deal. there are some revelations- "Aura Lee" is the basis for "Love Me Tender" and "Just before the Battle, Mother" is clearly the source for Woody Guthrie's "Hobo Lullaby".
There is an obvious omission. Classic country stars and the hottest new folk country acts.
What? No Civil Wars?!?!?
Seriously, though as some have pointed out. It's a very white compilation that largely leaves out the era's spirituals.
It's also a pretty sad compilation in that it seems to focus on ballads more than marches or uptempo songs.
These are the biggest complaints in that it generally works, but it gets very same-y after awhile.
Steve Earle has done a lot with Civil war imagery and his duet with Dirk Powell is a highlight.
It is a collection of Civil war-era songs (both sides) as performed by a collection of bluegrass, traditional country, and Americana stars.
Clearly, the aim is to make a "OBrother Where Art Thou" or Will the circle be Unbroken.
The artist roster is well done- Dolly Parton, Loretta Lynn, Del McCoury, Ricky Skaggs, Lee Ann Womack, Ralph Stanley, Old Crow medicine Show, Vince Gill, Steve Earle, John Doe, Chris Thile (Nickel Creek), Pokey LaFarge, Jorma Kauoken (Hot Tuna/Jefferson Airplane), Joe Henry, Taj Mahal, Chris Hillman, and Cowboy Jack Clement.
Artists have gotten some mileage from Civil War-themed songs, but this project promises the real deal. there are some revelations- "Aura Lee" is the basis for "Love Me Tender" and "Just before the Battle, Mother" is clearly the source for Woody Guthrie's "Hobo Lullaby".
There is an obvious omission. Classic country stars and the hottest new folk country acts.
What? No Civil Wars?!?!?
Seriously, though as some have pointed out. It's a very white compilation that largely leaves out the era's spirituals.
It's also a pretty sad compilation in that it seems to focus on ballads more than marches or uptempo songs.
These are the biggest complaints in that it generally works, but it gets very same-y after awhile.
Steve Earle has done a lot with Civil war imagery and his duet with Dirk Powell is a highlight.